A few days ago, while scrolling through the Mercedes-Benz EQS/EQS SUV Facebook group, I stumbled upon an intriguing post from Srikanth Katrue. His post read, "Hello everyone, what has been your maintenance on EQS SUV first few years? My wife is debating between EQS 580 SUV three-row vs Kia EV9 vs Tesla Model X. Any help is appreciated." His question sparked a lively debate among group members, and the responses provided an insightful perspective on the real-world ownership experiences of these three electric SUVs. For anyone considering a high-end, three-row EV, the choices can be dizzying. Srikanth’s dilemma is understandable—how do you choose between the futuristic luxury of a Mercedes-Benz EQS 580, the family-friendly practicality of a Kia EV9, and the cutting-edge tech and performance of the Tesla Model X? Let’s break it down, starting with the community’s responses. Real-World Advice from EQS, Tesla, and Kia Owners Sam Elenia weighed in with a compelling perspective, saying, "Get a used 3-row 2024 EQS 580 for the price of Kia and luxury that's unparalleled to Tesla. Tesla is more fun to drive though. I went from Model X to Model S and now EQS 580. I also advise that you try to rent an EQS and Model X for 24 hours. My wife prefers Tesla for reasons that I can't comprehend while I prefer EQS and I dislike Tesla. I would get a 2024 EQS over the 2023 mostly because of the brakes glitch and a little bit more miles." Jo Ki added an emphatic take: "You really can’t compare the three. Only one of those is a luxury vehicle. Depends on what you want, but if it’s luxury, then it’s Mercedes." Meanwhile, Christopher Barclay shared a more nuanced view: "Have her drive the 580, then it will be easy as the other two are a step down in luxury and comfort. We just got rid of our Teslas and bought a 2024 EQE SUV and EQS. Could not be happier. After coming from Tesla, I had forgotten what good service was. My Tesla was not a good experience." Sam Fran chimed in, "Definitely EQS 580. I had a Tesla and switched to EQS 580. It's a great car. My partner has Kia and the ride is not the same as EQS. You can't compare it." Interestingly, Pakman Pak offered a balanced viewpoint: "I have both the EQS and the Rivian R1S. Both are awesome in their own way." And Grayson Ang, a moderator, brought up an important consideration for budget-conscious buyers: "EV9 will probably be more reliable and cheaper to repair out of warranty." So, what should Srikanth and others in a similar position consider when choosing among these three impressive electric SUVs? Here’s a deeper dive into their pros and cons. The Mercedes-Benz EQS 580 SUV: A Pinnacle of Electric Luxury Advantages: