Last year, Tesla’s used car prices started to drop along with the rest of the used car market in the US. However, when the market started to recover in March 2025, Tesla’s used car prices didn’t. It continued to drop. Advertisement - scroll for more content In fact, it has now dropped so much that the average used Tesla vehicle costs less than the average used car on Car Gurus: This is unprecedented. Although the brand has taken a significant hit over the last year, Tesla is still regarded as a premium brand in the industry. The fact that its average used car sale price would dip below the industry average, which includes inexpensive mass-market vehicles, is quite exceptional. Used Tesla car prices are now down 4.59% year-over-year, compared to the market average being up 1.22%: Make/Model